The line between constructive criticism and destructive commentary is thin, often dangerously crossed, with players bearing the consequences. In football, opinions are everywhere, from pundits dissecting every match to fans on social media voicing their views. And while feedback can drive growth, the sheer volume and intensity of opinions can damage confidence, sometimes irreparably.

One recent example stands out. Real Madrid’s Vinicius Jr., known for his electrifying style, has faced a whirlwind of commentary, many questioning his tactical decisions, his attitude, or even his worth at Real Madrid. Despite his talent, the criticisms hit hard, sparking debates not just on his playing style but on his character. Imagine being 22, tasked with carrying the hopes of millions, yet scrutinised at every turn.

It’s easy to overlook that behind every number on the pitch, there’s a person. And in an age where everyone has a platform, opinions have transformed from mere sideline banter to powerful judgments that can alter a player’s trajectory. We often forget that opinions are fundamentally subjective—one person’s view shaped by personal expectations, biases, and a limited view of a player’s journey. What happens when a player, especially a young one, absorbs this barrage of judgments? How many dreams have been stifled, or worst-case scenario destroyed, by words?

The Impact of Judgment on Mental Health

Take the case of England’s Harry Kane. Although Kane is one of the best footballers of his generation, it wasn’t always the case. He started playing football at a very young age. At 8 years old, he played for the Arsenal youth academy but he was far from a star player at that time. Later, former head of academy recruitment at Spur’s—where Kane played—Richard Allen, said that during Harry’s first days, one of the coaches said to him “Who is that fat kid?” Harry was only 11 years old at that time.

Kane has achieved feats most players only dream of. Yet, whenever his form dips, the criticism ramps up. People question his fitness, his dedication, even his loyalty. How does this affect a player who, by all measures, has proven himself repeatedly? Does the constant questioning shake his self-belief?

For younger players, the stakes are even higher. Joao Felix, once hailed as a prodigy, has been under scrutiny since he joined Atletico Madrid for a record-breaking fee. With such a price tag comes enormous pressure, and any misstep becomes magnified. Fans and analysts dissect each decision, each goal missed, each game lost. Felix’s form, confidence, and even happiness visibly wavered at times. Yet, how many of these judgments take into account the immense pressures he faces?

Kylian Mbappe, already a world champion at a young age, has experienced similar waves of public opinion. He’s been praised for his natural talent, then criticised for alleged arrogance. His confidence, which fans love when he’s winning, becomes a flaw when his team falls short. When does constructive criticism morph into something destructive, something that, instead of building a player, chips away at his confidence?

The psychological toll is undeniable. Anxiety, self-doubt, and even depression aren’t uncommon in elite players, who are expected to be both physically and mentally resilient under constant public pressure.

Behind the scenes, however, many struggle. Their passion becomes a burden, as every performance is weighed, analysed, and judged by millions.

Resilience in the Face of Criticism

Then there are the players who push through at all costs.

Jamie Vardy: His story stands out as a beacon for every aspiring player facing doubts. Rejected by major clubs in his youth, Vardy spent years climbing the lower leagues. By the time he joined Leicester City, few expected him to make an impact. But Vardy believed in his potential, and that belief paid off. In 2016, he was instrumental in Leicester’s historic Premier League win. His journey is a reminder that opinions don’t define potential—determination does.

Kevin De Bruyne: His story underscores the importance of resilience. Early in his career, he faced rejection at Chelsea, a blow that could have deterred him. Yet, De Bruyne pushed forward, eventually finding his stride at Manchester City, where he now ranks among the world’s best. His experience is a testament to the idea that setbacks and opinions are temporary, but persistence builds lasting success.

Steven Gerrard: Throughout his time at Liverpool, Gerrard faced a mix of admiration and intense scrutiny. Known for his loyalty to the club, he was often questioned for his decision to stay despite offers from other top teams. His infamous slip in the 2013-14 season drew relentless criticism, overshadowing his otherwise illustrious career. Yet, Gerrard’s resilience and commitment never wavered, and he remained a Liverpool icon. His journey serves as a reminder that even legends face setbacks and criticism, but self-belief and dedication can ultimately define a career.

Cafu: The Brazilian right-back also faced his share of opinions, particularly regarding his style of play and physicality. Early in his career, some critics doubted his ability to thrive in the physically demanding European leagues, given his offensive style as a full-back. Yet, Cafu’s work ethic and skill proved them wrong. He went on to become the only player to appear in three World Cup finals, winning two, and established himself as one of the best in his position. His story is a testament to how talent and determination can transcend opinions.

Encouragement for Aspiring Players

For every young player striving to break through, the message is clear: focus on your path. There will always be opinions—some will offer valuable insights, while others will be harsh, even hurtful.

But remember that an opinion is just that: one person’s view, not an absolute truth. Learn to separate constructive feedback from noise.

Antoine Griezmann, a player known for his resilience and adaptability, has been open about his struggles with criticism and self-doubt. He has acknowledged the need to protect his mental well-being, recognising that public opinion doesn’t define his worth. This mindset is crucial for anyone chasing a football dream. It’s easy to be swayed by external voices, but the only opinion that truly matters is the one you hold of yourself.

Young players entering the world of professional football should expect scrutiny—it’s part of the job. But they should also remember that every legend, from Ronaldo to Messi, faced doubts and criticism. Many of today’s stars, like Bernardo Silva and Griezmann, use these doubts as fuel. They learn from valid feedback but refuse to be weighed down by opinions.

The Power of Self-Belief

Football is as much a mental game as it is physical. When opinions start to feel overwhelming, remember Vardy’s journey, Kane’s resilience, and Felix’s ongoing growth. Believe in your potential, even when the world questions it. Every player has their own pace, their own journey. You may not win over every critic, and that’s okay. Opinions are temporary, but a strong self-belief will carry you through the most challenging times.

The journey of a footballer is filled with ups and downs. How many players have been discouraged from their path by harsh words? How many dreams have ended before they truly began? It’s easy to critique from the stands, but the real challenge is on the field.

So, to every young player, stay true to your path. Listen to the voices that push you to improve, but never let the white noise define you.

Listen to Three.Six.Zero Player Management’s podcast Pitch Talk: Unfiltered on YouTube titled Opinions in Football. To learn more, visit Three Six Zero Player Management’s website.